The man who invented the American curry craze was a fraud who claimed to be a prince. Ranji Smile fabricated this royal persona from Baluchistan to secure financial backing from financier Roland R. Conklin for his ambitious venture. He didn't just cook; he orchestrated an elaborate dining theater that captivated early twentieth-century New Yorkers. This calculated deception laid the groundwork for India’s culinary entry into the United States market.

Ranji Smile and the first Indian restaurant in America

Smile launched Omar Khayyam at 325 Fifth Avenue in 1901, likely establishing the first Indian restaurant in the US. Before arriving in New York, he worked as a curry cook at London's Savoy Hotel, where Louis Sherry recruited him for his establishment. Smile arrived illegally by trafficking staff, including valets and mahouts, under false pretenses of attending King Edward VII's coronation. These covert arrivals fueled the exotic allure of his new dining destination.

Diners were mesmerized by Smile’s performance, wearing a satin coat and blue turban while asking customers 'Will you have the curry hot or mild, sahib?' His theatrical presence turned every meal into a spectacle of Eastern mystique and hospitality. Despite initial fame, his restaurant failed within a year because New Yorkers dismissed Indian food as a passing fad. The public appetite for authenticity vanished faster than the heat of the dishes themselves.

Smile’s rapid rise and fall reveal how quickly novelty can overshadow substance in the culinary world. Today, we enjoy a vast array of Indian cuisines across America, yet few remember the risky gamble that started it all. Would modern diners still pay for the theater if the flavor didn't sustain them? The legacy of that single Fifth Avenue failure remains a cautionary tale for every food pioneer.